• About
    • Login
    View Item 
    •   Institutional Repository Home
    • Law School
    • Vanderbilt Law School Faculty Works
    • View Item
    •   Institutional Repository Home
    • Law School
    • Vanderbilt Law School Faculty Works
    • View Item
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    Browse

    All of Institutional RepositoryCommunities & CollectionsBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsDepartmentThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsDepartment

    My Account

    LoginRegister

    Tonal Concept and Feel

    Fishman, Joseph
    : http://hdl.handle.net/1803/17193
    : 2021

    Abstract

    In the world of music-copyright litigation, “feel” has lately become a controversial word. Musical feel, some have argued, is becoming too propertized. When a jury in 2015 found the writers of the hit song “Blurred Lines” liable for infringing Marvin Gaye’s “Got to Give It Up,” observers protested that the two songs’ true point of similarity was nothing more than their shared feel—something that should be freely available to anyone. Pharrell Williams, one of the defendants, similarly tried to explain his disagreement with the outcome by insisting that “you can’t copyright a feeling.” In the few years since, the same criticism has been leveled against subsequent, equally newsworthy infringement trials involving Led Zeppelin and Katy Perry. Those claims eventually lost, unlike the one in the Blurred Lines case, but they still proved remarkably hard to shake. After failing to secure a dismissal on summary judgment, Led Zeppelin won at trial, only to see that verdict overturned on appeal; it took a rare en banc rehearing for the noninfringement verdict to be reinstated—six years after the case began. The Katy Perry claim, meanwhile, would have ended in liability had the trial judge not vacated the jury’s infringement verdict, a decision that at the time of this writing remains on appeal. Where a song’s compositional details end and its overarching gestalt begins is, of course, endlessly contestable. Pretty much everyone agrees that a song’s feel—whatever that is—shouldn’t be proprietary.
    Show full item record

    Files in this item

    Icon
    Name:
    Tonal_Concept_and_Feel.pdf
    Size:
    1.715Mb
    Format:
    PDF
    Description:
    published article
    View/Open

    This item appears in the following collection(s):

    • Vanderbilt Law School Faculty Works

    Connect with Vanderbilt Libraries

    Your Vanderbilt

    • Alumni
    • Current Students
    • Faculty & Staff
    • International Students
    • Media
    • Parents & Family
    • Prospective Students
    • Researchers
    • Sports Fans
    • Visitors & Neighbors

    Support the Jean and Alexander Heard Libraries

    Support the Library...Give Now

    Gifts to the Libraries support the learning and research needs of the entire Vanderbilt community. Learn more about giving to the Libraries.

    Become a Friend of the Libraries

    Quick Links

    • Hours
    • About
    • Employment
    • Staff Directory
    • Accessibility Services
    • Contact
    • Vanderbilt Home
    • Privacy Policy