Associations Between Emotion Reactivity and Depressive Symptoms: A Multimethod Investigation
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Depression is associated with broad alterations to individuals’ emotional responses to stimuli. However, studies often yield findings supporting contradictory hypotheses that imply disparate approaches to the prevention and treatment of depressive disorders. The primary goal of this series of studies was to evaluate variability in the relation between emotion reactivity and depressive symptoms across different measurement and statistical approaches. In Study 1, findings were compared across self-report measures using a conventional questionnaire and four different multilevel measures in a sample of 712 general population adults. The questionnaire method revealed that depressive symptoms were related to lower positive and higher negative emotion reactivity; however, these relations were largely explained by individuals’ average affect. The four multilevel emotion reactivity approaches generated highly consistent findings that positive and negative emotion reactivity are negatively related to depressive symptoms, even controlling for individuals’ average affect. In Study 2, analyses were conducted to compare traditional and multilevel approaches for electroencephalogram data analysis using the late positive potential, an event-related potential, as an index of emotion reactivity in response to standardized images in a sample of 165 adolescents at varying risk for depression. Findings yielded partial support for study hypotheses, with some results suggesting blunted associations between multilevel estimates of reactivity and depressive symptoms, but no significant differences between traditional and multilevel estimates. These results provide preliminary evidence suggesting that variability in the relation of emotion reactivity to depressive symptoms depends in part on the measures used to assess emotion reactivity and that multilevel approaches may offer advantages for estimates of LPP reactivity. Further study is needed to clarify what factors underlie discrepancies across measures, particularly for estimates of emotion reactivity derived from EEG and self-report approaches.