China’s Debate over Entry into World War I: Deciding National Survival in Crisis, 1917
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This thesis examines China’s entry-to-war debate in 1917, during which the country’s political and intellectual elites, as well as citizens concerned about China’s future, debated how the nation should respond to an external shock originating in Europe: the ongoing First World War. This thesis contributes to existing scholarship in several ways. First, it brings attention to this largely overlooked topic in both Chinese and English-language scholarship. Second, it offers a more systematic analysis of the arguments advanced by both sides of the debate, focusing on why the pro-entry and anti-entry camps adopted their respective positions rather than merely describing what those positions were. In this sense, the thesis moves beyond stance classification toward deeper explanation. Third, it draws upon a broad range of understudied primary sources, including government correspondence, telegrams, editorials, essays, letters, newspaper coverage, and journal publications from February to August 1917, to illustrate the recurring discourse of key individuals and trace the step-by-step development of the debate. In doing so, the thesis reconstructs a more complete six-month chronology while paying particular attention to how the conflict escalated over time. Most importantly, this thesis argues that China’s entry-to-war debate in 1917 was not merely a diplomatic episode, but a critical moment in which competing visions of national survival were articulated and contested within an unstable political and social climate. The pro-entry camp framed participation in World War I as a final opportunity to save China from further destruction, while the anti-entry camp regarded neutrality as essential to national preservation and viewed war participation as detrimental to national survival. Despite their opposition, both sides grounded their arguments in a shared belief that China faced a life-or-death crisis in 1917. The pro-entry camp, driven by desperation, placed strong hopes in the potential benefits of war participation; by contrast, the anti-entry camp, motivated by similar anxieties, distrusted those expectations and feared that entering the war would inflict further harm upon China. These opposing yet comparable interpretations of national survival intensified political divisions between the two camps and escalated the debate from disagreement, to deadlock, and ultimately to destabilization. In this process, the debate reveals the institutional fragility of early Republican China, the fragmentation of warlord politics, and the country’s vulnerability to foreign influence.